Honoring My Daughter
February 21, 2007 by mrschili
You know that feeling where it seems like it’s all piling up on you at once?
I’ve been dealing with some pretty tough stuff at work. My students seem to be slipping as the term draws to a close. They’re sending me abominable emails, they’re turning in half-done homework - or refusing to do it at all - and I’m watching with mingled horror and confusion and sadness as a good portion of them go down in a spectacular show of smoke and flames.
If that weren’t enough (or, perhaps, because I’m seeing all of this at work and am more sensitive to it at home), my nearly-ten-year-old seems to be entering a new phase in her development. Never having been the parent of a nearly-ten-year-old before, I’m not entirely sure I’m quite ready to deal with what she’s got to give.
Some examples of her new behavior include the usual pre-teen eye rolling (she’s really rather good at that - I expect she and her girlfriends practice at school) and other dismissive behaviours (though I totally claim responsibility for her occasional responses of “whatever!”). She’s also started whining about almost everything that doesn’t happen according to her wishes - dinnertime, bedtime, whether or not dessert is served on a particular evening, going to or leaving from someplace. She’s becoming bossy with Beanie or anyone who she sees as somehow inferior to herself, and has taken to blatant tattling - which I find amusing because of the whole glass houses thing, but she doesn’t get that. There are a number of other disagreeable things she’s been doing lately, but the most grating to me is that she’s starting to refuse to participate in the things that have to happen to keep our family running.
She’s not responsible for anything but herself and her things, really. She doesn’t yet have chores - she doesn’t have to feed the cats or empty the dishwasher or vacuum - and that’s mostly because she’s still not behaving responsibly when it comes to herself and her things. There are lists on the fridge of things that need to be done before and after school and before bed. These lists contain things like “make your bed” and “get dressed,” or “finish your homework and put it in your book bag,” or “bring your plates to the table” and “get into your pajamas and brush your teeth.” We still have to drag her - item by item - through these things, and I haven’t felt good about adding other things to the list if she can’t manage what’s already there.
The kids are on vacation this week. This afternoon, after going out to lunch with Daddy, we girls came home and spent a little quiet time on our own; Beanie read, I did some grading and Punkin’ Pie played with clay. I had asked them, on the way home, if they would help me do some light housekeeping in the afternoon - I wanted to vacuum the downstairs and do a quick, light mopping of the wood floors. I told them that they could help with those things, or they could do something else that was helpful - tidying their room, picking up and sorting their laundry so I can run it through the machines, dusting, that sort of thing.
Beanie was willing to help - she went into the room to get a little tidying done (which, really, wasn’t any great shakes as I’d been in there earlier today and had already DONE most of the tidying, but whatever). I asked Punkin’ Pie if she’d take the laundry basket into their room and sort out the darks and lights. She took the basket, went into her room, then promptly yelled, “I don’t FEEL like doing laundry!”
Here’s my question: do I somehow compel her to do laundry, or do I leave her to run out of clean clothes? Do I tell her that I don’t FEEL like washing and folding her clothes, and make that her responsibility now? I didn’t respond to her outburst at the time because I didn’t have anything useful to say, but it’s certainly something that needs to be addressed - and soon.
I’m saddened by the idea that she’s not willing to cooperate - one of the things that I treasure about my family life up to this point is that we all worked together, for the most part, to keep things humming along. How do I get across to her that her input in the family is vital - that we not only want her, but need her to participate? How do I keep her engaged without putting her in a position of power that might encourage more of this same kind of behaviour?
I love my children beyond reasoning. I want to parent them in the very best way, and I am willing to do a lot to hold up my end of the cosmic deal I have with my girls. I want to honor them by doing the best job I can, and by helping them become strong, competent, responsible adults. It’s starting to get a little harder now, and I could use a little advice.





Ah yes, the next phase!! Did she actually REFUSE to do the laundry,or did she simply voice an opinion? I trusted the “there are consequences” route myself. If the laundry hadn’t gotten collected,oh well! “Oh,you don’t have a clean shirt? Gee, I already washed all the dirty clothes that were put into the laundry area” And then there was the memorable “I’m a vegetarian. I shouldn’t have to wash the roast pan that meat was cooked in” incident.
Oh boy! I know what you mean. Em started doing her own laundry when she was 12, but if yours can handle it now, go for it.
When i hear the “i don’t feel like….” line, i always responded, “Well i don’t feel like it either, so i understand. Let’s get going.”
Sometimes humor will work, sometimes yelling, sometimes nothing helps. She is probably going to try this stuff for a while, just to see if it works.
Claudia, remind me how the roast pan story goes, please - I remember it being a good one, but I’ve forgotten the punch line.
It’s that detachment that I need to work on - being able to say “Oh? You don’t have any clean clothes? How did THAT happen? I KNOW I did laundry this week, because I’ve got plenty of clean stuff…” Please help to remind me that these are HER lessons, and that I won’t serve her by getting caught up in it…
I’ve been thinking about responding to the words and not the tone. Or not responding to either. So that, in the laundry scenario, you do just address the words, “I know, I don’t feel like doing these floors either, thanks so much for helping me get all this not fun stuff done so we can do (whatever’s next and fun) sooner.” I used to know a mother (probably more than one) who simply wouldn’t respond to whining. Her kids would ask for something in a whiny tone and then keep asking and she’d say, “Sorry, I can’t hear you when you whine like that.” Asked nicely she would respond nicely. In the laundry scenario I think that’d play out as no response until she was seen again and then a pleasant check in “Oh, cool, are you done already?” The challenge for me would be to keep the judgement out of my tone even when my words were nice.
Yeah, with my students, it’s the tone that gets me too. I can manage the words, but my tone betrays me.
You brought up a VERY important point. She is entering a phase. Do not forget that. She is testing limits and is looking for a response from you so you better make it a good one. One of the things that works with “my” kids is saying something like ” I would like you to help me with…” They want to please you and if they know in advance it will make you happy then they are more likely to help out. And I never respond to whining or demands for that matter. I use the humour route a lot. “Do you hear someone whinning? Hmm, maybe it was the wind!” They think it’s funny and respond to it better than a firm “Don’t talk to me like that.” Although sometimes that is in order.
It is very important to not get caught up in the moment and don’t let them push your buttons. Once they know what buttons to push, you’rer done. And again, little people look to adults to learn how to respond.
I am a firm believer of natural consequences. In order for them to work you must remain consistant!! And don’t try to have a conversation with her while she is digging her heels in. Give her some time and space and than have the chat. And don’t forget to validate her feelings!
You better get this sorted out before i have them in March! I will kick her right in the pants! Just kidding!
I’m actually really proud of how I handled that situation. At the time, I happened to be on the floor, shoulder-deep in cleaning up a spill under the counters. I was really in no position to respond, so I let it go. I had nothing positive to say in the moment anyway, so I chose to release it rather than engage her in a battle of wills.
We had a conversation about it later, and she decided she would sort the laundry. We discussed not only the consequences of not doing so (I’m only going to wash the laundry that gets sorted and brought out, so whatever you don’t feel like doing, I’m not washing) but also the consequences of non-cooperation in the family unit (unless and until we can all work together smoothly again, certain privileges will be denied). We have every right to expect them - both of them - to handle their lists and take care of thier things, so we’re going to be more insistent about that. They need to understand that they run the risk of losing things they leave lying around in family spaces and that Mom and Dad aren’t going to bring forgotten things to school for them.
I recognize it as a marathon. Every once in a while, though, I feel myself “hitting the wall.”
Mile 20 is a killer. Have some Gatorade and re-adjust your underwear, then keep going.
And breathe. I have no experience from which to offer advice, but I have a story. Starting about a month or 2 before my wedding, I started a new mantra. “I loved him before, I’ll love him again when this is over.” It turned out I was right. It could be adjusted for the teen years.
I have a niece ’round that age. She’s overly sensitive and if she pushes and you push back she collapses in tears and storms out. I’ve found if she pushes and you ignore or offer the consequences, she’s much better.
That age sucks….too young to have too many responsibilities, too old to be babied.
You’re doing everything right. Make sure you take the time at the end of the day to explain that no matter how much you bicker, or are frustrated by each other, you love her very much.
Never having had children, I’ll pass on giving any advice about that. However, I will say: This Too Will Pass.