Monday Musing

It’s Banned Book Week.

It still floors me that, in 2013, we’re still fighting shit like this.  Seriously; it’s Ralph FUCKING Ellison’s INVISIBLE FUCKING MAN.  WHO in their right mind thinks that banning this book is a good idea?!

It’s not exactly about banning a book, but I’m reminded of an incident I had with a student a few years ago.  We were reading Native Son (another really tough book dealing with issues of race and poverty and all of the horrid things that attend the lives of people who are violently oppressed), and a student – let’s call her Betty – was choking hard on it.

She sent me an email after the second murder in the novel and said she just couldn’t do it and she wanted me to find another book for her to read.  Here’s the response I sent her:

Dear Betty,
    I understand that you’re upset right now, Honey, and I am genuinely sorry for that.  I want you to understand, though, that I think that the work that you’re doing is very important, and that I wouldn’t be asking you to do it if I didn’t think it was something you could handle.

    Native Son is a VERY difficult novel to get through.  I know that the graphic description of two of the key events is particularly troubling to you, and I fully appreciate why you feel that way; please don’t think for a moment that I don’t understand that.  What I want you to understand, though, is that those scenes are desperately important to the overall function of the novel.  

    One of the central ideas of this work is the brutality of the life that Bigger (and by extension, other oppressed people) live EVERY SINGLE DAY.  We don’t want to look at the ugliness; we don’t want to look at the desperation and the despair and the fear and the rage that are an everyday reality for people who find themselves in impossible situations with impossible choices.  We, as members of a privileged class – you and I are white, educated, reasonably wealthy people living in stable families in a reasonably safe and clean and well-appointed environment – can say we understand how other people live, but we really don’t see it; we can only imagine it.  It’s uncomfortable when we’re presented – full-on and in our faces – with the hard and cruel and brutal that other people have to live around all the time.  It’s supposed to be uncomfortable; it’s supposed to make you uneasy.  I want for you to use the skills of critical and professional distance that we’ve been practicing all year to take a step back from those scenes.  The point isn’t the graphic descriptions (though I know they’re hard to get around): the point is that Bigger doesn’t believe he has any other choices.

    What are the implications of that fact, and what kind of work can you do with that knowledge?  What kind of spin does that put on your thinking about current events, or about the reality that you and I get to participate in a system that deliberately and brutally excludes entire populations of people?  What does the investigation of Bigger’s reality – of his self-image and his self-esteem, of his prospects and his goals, of his aspirations and his dreams, of his relationships and the ways he believes he’s supposed to behave – do to the ways you think about yourself?  To the ways you think about our collective past?  To the ways you think about our present, and the policies, stereotypes, and assumptions that we continue to create (or to perpetuate)?  

    There’s a lot of really great thinking to be mined from this novel.  I’m eager to get Mr. Carson in to the class to help you all work through the history of the time period – and to see how some of those policies and attitudes are STILL in place today (have you been paying attention to all the racism that’s evident in our current political and national news?  Have you heard of Treyvon Martin and seen all the ugliness that his murder has stirred up?).  This novel is an important one for you to have in your arsenal; I know that you’re angry and upset, but I also know that you’re smart enough to get past that and to do some really significant thinking.

    Trust me, Betty; I have faith that you’re more than capable of getting through this, and of coming out on the other end with a deeper and more nuanced understanding of race, economics, and politics that will give you a really strong and impressive foundation for a lot of the work you’re going to be asked to do in college.  Remember, too, that I’m around to talk you through all of it; I don’t expect you to do any of this work on your own.


        Mrs.  Chili

Then she sent me this:

I am so grateful for this email. I understand where you are coming from and I understand that you’re helping me. This book is hard to digest at certain points but it does have some many important values. I know that the way I was raised I never had to see/feel those hardships. I am going to continue with this book and look at it in a more professional state of mind for now on. Once again thank you for explaining everything to me, I do feel better about it now.

She read the book and she did the thinking I asked her to do and she nailed the assessments that demonstrated that she understood not only the concepts, but how to apply them to other ideas and contexts.

TEACHERS should be making the decisions about which books their students should be reading.  Teachers know their kids, understand what they want them to be able to know and do, and are keenly attuned to what students can handle and under what circumstances or conditions.  Forgive me, but these decisions shouldn’t be made by parents (unless they homeschool) or school board members (unless they are also in the classroom) and under NO circumstances should a book (or any other kind of material) EVER be outright banned.

I still can’t believe we’re fighting these battles.



1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “Monday Musing

  1. Unreal!!! The fear of honesty and complexity.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s